22 Comments
User's avatar
Ara Fitzgerald's avatar

An important piece! Thank you. I appreciated reading history of this sceintific seed conflict, and its reverberations with the terrifying reality that we face with our authoritarian regime. May it be read widely!

Mark Schapiro's avatar

Thank you, Ara....as someone said, history doesn't repeat, it rhymes, or maybe it raps....or screams loudly....Thanks for the kind words, Glad the piece landed....!

Zoe FitzGerald Carter's avatar

Excellent piece! Really interesting parallels. And as Winston Churchill once said: "Those that fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it."

Jeffrey Day's avatar

Superb piece about historically distant events and right on point for today, sadly

David Rabin's avatar

A very sobering article. We are in a lot of trouble on so many levels!

Laurie's avatar

Excellent comparison and description of the Lysenko affair. Sadly there are so many parallels with Soviet & Russian history and that of other authoritarian states. We need to learn from history and being more aware of the paths that other countries have taken.

David Poulson's avatar

Mark,

Excellent stuff. I look forward to the book.

Dave

Mark Schapiro's avatar

Thanks, David! Good to hear from you. Book’s a ways off….! Hope you are well!

Christine Heinrichs's avatar

Stanford engineering professor Mark Jacobson has worked on this, in his No Miracles Needed (2023), and Still No Miracles Needed (2025).

Jay Letto's avatar

Well done, Mark, and I share your concerns. Meanwhile, the ridiculous comment by Douglass Allen comparing Michael Mann to Lysenko begs a response. First off, that would be great if true, because if Mann were Lysenko, then he'd be in charge of science in the Trump regime and not RFK and the other charlatans. This comment is a prime example of the 180-degree disinformation that is enabling the current dismantling of the greatest scientific establishment in the history of humankind. Mann's battles on behalf of peer-reviewed science and against science disinformation quite clearly make him the Nikolai Vavilov of today. And unless we figure out a way to stand up to and overwhelm the disinformation, then he, and all of us, may well have the same fate.

Elliott Negin's avatar

Jay Letto: Thanks for your comment. I just responded to Douglass Allen's upside-down, alternative-facts comment. In reality, Allen's heroine, Judith Curry, fits the bill as a modern day Lysenko. Feel free to pile on.

Douglass Allen's avatar

There's a very close comparison to what's happened here in the Unites States. Michael Mann is the Trofim Lysenko of today, promoting his ambition with lies that the wishful thinking "net zero" environmentalists and politicians want to hear, lies about the possibility of 50% reduction in emissions by 2030 and 80% by 2050, and lies about climate consensus, climate catastrophe, and green energy. And who is Nikolai Vavilov? Of all the scientists Mann has smeared, vilified, or sued, Judith Curry comes closest to being the Nikolai Vavilov. Study the history of climate science and climate/energy politics and you'll find how science (and energy policy) has been corrupted by money, ambition, fearmongering, and wishful thinking, going from one extreme, to now, the polar opposite with Trump.

Mark and Andrew, IMO, science and civility have been the casualties that we see all around us, including the thesis of this historically fascinating, but this poorly thought out, suggested comparison.

Elliott Negin's avatar

Douglass Allen: You have it backward. The Energy Department's National Renewable Energy Laboratory concluded back in 2012 that that the commercially available renewable technologies available at the time could adequately generate 80 percent of U.S. electricity by 2050. Michael Mann did not make that up. Judith Curry, on the other hand, is a prime example of a modern day Lysenko. She was one of the "fraudulent five" who produced a widely debunked report for the Trump Energy Department that the Trump EPA used to justify killing climate regulations. Money Trail reported on her bogus report in late July. (See https://themoneytrail.substack.com/p/epa-rationale-for-ending-climate.) In early September, a group of more than 85 climate scientists issued a comprehensive rebuttal to her report, finding that it was full of errors and misrepresentations. (See https://www.npr.org/2025/09/02/nx-s1-5521384/energy-report-scientists-climate-change.) Curry and her four colleagues are outliers. There is a scientific consensus worldwide that fossil fuels are largely responsible for driving up temperatures, which turbocharge extreme weather events (see https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/scientific-consensus/). I don't know where you get your information, but the verifiable facts say otherwise.

Douglass Allen's avatar

Elliot,

I need more assistance. I just spent an hour rereading, first time in years, the 2012 Energy Department's National Renewable Energy Laboratory 2012 report that you claim states that commercially available renewable technologies available in 2012 could adequately generate 80 percent of U.S. electricity by 2050. I can not find that claim. Maybe you can? See- https://docs.nrel.gov/docs/fy14osti/60197.pdf

It does offer a comprehensive U.S. and global view of energy generation and consumption back then. There's unfortunately been no reduction in CO2 emissions in these past 13 years. Read the 2012 report and consult recent information to verify that.

Please others, also check out Elliot's above claims and references for veracity and validity. I don't blame Elliot for presenting the claims as true or factual, but I do blame Michael Mann and others for their mis- and dis-information. IMO, Mann is very similar to Trump and, as I written on Andrew Revkin's substack and elsewhere, I blame the dis-information, and especially the character assassinations, by Mann and his followers for helping to fuel the MAGA movement. When you call people "deniers", "fraudulent", and "enemies of humanity, you" create anger, hurt, and political opposition. I watched that grow over the years that I taught climate science and since. I don't know how we are going to get out of the terrible mess we've created, do you? Does anyone?

Elliott Negin's avatar

I cited that NREL report in an article I wrote in 2012, so it may have been published the year before. The hyperlink I included in my article no longer works. But I did find this report that NREL published more recently: https://www.nrel.gov/grid/naris. It states: "The future low-carbon system can balance supply and demand in a wide range of future conditions, with all technologies contributing to resource adequacy. In the United States, between 1,200 and 2,000 gigawatts of renewable energy can be deployed to produce 70%–80% of U.S. electricity by 2050 while meeting planning reserve requirements. In Canada, hydropower, gas, and wind technologies contribute most to resource adequacy in the future system."

It also states: "Multiple pathways can lead to 80% power-sector carbon reduction continent-wide by 2050. Steeper cost reduction of wind and solar technologies can lead to a faster and less costly transition, and carbon targets can still be achieved with conservative wind and solar cost assumptions. When it comes to total system costs of reaching 80% reduction in power-sector carbon emissions, wind and solar cost trajectories have a more significant impact than carbon policy assumptions."

I can assure you that I am very careful about citing reputable sources.

To wrap it up, If you aren't concerned about the increasing number of climate change-related extreme weather disasters, mounting temperatures, and rising sea levels, and you think the climate scientists who are sounding the alarm about them are somehow engaged in a worldwide conspiracy, you are way off-base.

If you want to blame anyone for the politicization of science, blame the fossil fuel industry and the GOP--the Gas and Oil Party--which it subsidizes. Michael Mann did not create or fuel the MAGA movement. Blame Charles Koch (who also underwrote the tea party movement) and Rex Tillerson (and his predecessor at ExxonMobil, Lee Raymond), who spent more than anyone else on climate disinformation over the last 35 years. (If you google my name and Charles Koch and/or ExxonMobil you will find plenty of documentation of their outsized role.)

How do we get out of this mess? First, you can stop attacking reputable scientists and applauding scientists such as Judith Curry who confuse the public about the mess we're in by claiming we aren't in a mess at all.

I have to focus my attention on articles we plan to post next week, so I am not going to be able to respond anymore. Peace.

Douglass Allen's avatar

Elliott,

Help me find that IPCC quote that climate change “is causing more frequent and intense extreme weather events resulting in widespread adverse impacts and related losses and damages to nature and people.” What I find in the IPCC 6th Assessment, chapter11 is the uncontroversial "It is an established fact that human-induced greenhouse gas emissions have led to an increased frequency and/or intensity of some weather and climate extremes since pre-industrial time, in particular for temperature extremes". There's no controversy about the 1.2 C global warming since the industrial revolution or that anthropogenic CO2 emissions are responsible for at least 50% of it (IPCC 4th and 5th Assessment).

Yes, Curry and the her colleagues are outliers. You do remember Einstein's famous quote about scientific consensus or Richard Feynman's many similar quotes?

Elliott, can you show ANY of Judith Curry's SPECIFIC claims that have been debunked by Michael Mann or anyone else, or is the "fraudulent five" character assassination proof enough for you?

BTW, I am not particularly in favor of ending the "climate regs" or withdrawing from the UNFCCC or COP30, but I am definitely in favor of empirical science and the back and forth papers, claims, and criticism which is responsible for science's self-correction. Democracy needs respectful voices who listen to each other. And as Patrick Moynihan famously said, "You can have your own opinions, but not your own facts".

Elliott Negin's avatar

Curry was an author of the debunked DOE report I mentioned in my response. You can find a link to the rebuttal by more than 85 scientists in the NPR story I provided in my response to your comment.

Besides that, check out Skeptical Science's rebuttal of Curry's assertion that the IPCC 95% confidence in human-caused global warming "is incomprehensible.... IPCC projections are overconfident." You can find it here: https://skepticalscience.com/ipcc-human-caused-global-warming-attribution-confidence.htm. The article maintains that "the IPCC confidence in human-caused global warming is based on solid scientific research."

Skeptical Science summed it up this way: "A few naysayers like Judith Curry from Georgia Tech have disputed the IPCC confidence on this question, for example in an interview with the reliably inaccurate David Rose.

"However, while Curry is a climate scientist, she doesn't research the causes of global warming. She also has a history of exaggerating climate uncertainties. Her comments are inconsistent with the body of scientific research on the subject. Put simply, she is speaking outside her area of expertise, like a podiatrist giving advice on open heart surgery."

Einstein and Feynman's quotes notwithstanding, Curry and her colleagues are not credible. Do you really believe that there is a worldwide conspiracy among climate scientists to perpetrate a fraud and Curry and her pals are valiant truth tellers?

I couldn't agree more with Moynihan's observation--and in this case, you are ignoring the facts.

environMENTAL's avatar

Jesus, Elliot. Just stop.

When you are “rebutting” the former chair of earth and atmospheric sciences at Georgia Tech, who has 196 authored/co-authored papers in peer reviewed climate science literature, by referring to non-scientist, climate-political-Goebbels John Cook’s Skeptical Science website you have actually unequivocally become hypnotized by the Lysenkoism Douglas is referring to without even knowing it.

Mark’s article has it wrong and so does Andy.

We are energy, environmental, economic, ideologues, not partisans. We think both parties suck, OK.

But you, Mark and Andy completely ignoring the idea that what you are witnessing (at least with respect to “climate”) is analogous not to 1939 but instead the post Lysenko cleanup of Soviet agriculture after Stalin.

Not to mention the fact that Lysenkoism was a Communist - Leftist - construct; and govt and its edifices silencing critics and out of mainstream scientists is where we have been for 20 odd years in the West. Judy Curry was one of them. Until she read their emails in the ClimateGate hack.

How do I know this? Because I have personally known her since 2009 and discussed it face to face.

Consider the possibility that you have it completely backwards.

Jon-Marc Seimon's avatar

Keep shining the light, Mr Schapiro! The truth WILL ultimately prevail, as it does, and the record of the needless carnage being wreaked by this clueless and reckless regime will be a signal part of that truth.